Description

Kline et al developed a rule for avoiding unnecessary diagnostic testing of patients in the Emergency Department suspected of having a pulmonary embolism (PE). The authors are from Carolinas Medical Center in Charlotte, Massachusetts General Hospital, Mayo Clinic Phoenix in Scottsdale and Northwestern Memorial Hospital I Chicago


Patient selection: Emergency Department with suspected pulmonary embolism, but considered low or very low risk by the clinician (a negative D-dimer test sufficient to exclude PE)

 

Parameters:

(1) age in years

(2) pulse in beats per minute

(3) oxygen saturation in percent on room air by pulse oximetry

(4) cough

(5) hemoptysis

(6) unilateral leg swelling

(7) recent surgery or trauma

(8) history of prior pulmonary embolism (PE) or deep vein thrombosis (DVT)

(9) oral hormone use

(10) asthma, COPD or wheezing

 

Parameter

Finding

Rule

age in years

< 50 years

0

 

>= 50 years

1

pulse in beats per minute

< 100 per minute

0

 

>= 100 per minute

1

oxygen saturation

>= 95%%

0

 

<= 94%

1

hemoptysis

absent

0

 

present

1

unilateral leg swelling

absent

0

 

present

1

recent surgery or trauma

absent

0

 

present

1

history of PE or DVT

absent

0

 

present

1

oral hormone use

absent

0

 

present

1

 

 

Parameter

Finding

Equation

age in years

<= 50 years

0

 

> 50 years

0.5449

pulse in beats per minute

<= 100 per minute

0

 

> 100 per minute

0.451

oxygen saturation

>= 95%%

0

 

< 95%%

1.2049

cough

absent

0

 

present

-0.3768

hemoptysis

absent

0

 

present

1.0382

unilateral leg swelling

absent

0

 

present

1.0844

recent surgery or trauma

absent

0

 

present

0.6651

history of PE or DVT

absent

0

 

present

0.6354

oral hormone use

absent

0

 

present

0.5166

asthma, COPD, wheezing

absent

0

 

present

-0.6072

 

where:

• Age and heart rate differ in the cut-offs between the 2 equations.

• Cough and asthma/COPD/wheezing are in the logistic regression model but not the rule.

 

rule score =

= SUM(points for all 8 parameters)

 

X for logistic regression model =

= SUM(points for all 10 parameters) –3.1246

 

probability of PE =

= 1 / (1 + EXP((-1) * X))

 

Interpretation:

• minimum score for rule score: 0

• maximum score for rule score: 8

• A rule score of 0 indicates a patient in the ED at low risk for pulmonary embolism and may not need additional diagnostic testing.

 

Performance:

• The performance has varied in different study. One source of variation is use in a population NOT considered low risk by the clinician.


To read more or access our algorithms and calculators, please log in or register.